Supervising apprentices is a very important part of managing a successful apprenticeship.
However, should apprentices be supervised at all times? Can you leave them unsupervised for a period?
The fact that there can be these questions and this confusion around the topic of apprentice supervision guidelines means that the rules and regulations are maybe not clear to everybody.
This lack of clarity can lead to some issues with being overly supervised, which means that productivity can suffer. Another, and more serious, problem is that the lack of supervision can create safety issues and legal risks, which should be avoided at all costs.
We will explain the rules and obligations that employers need to follow when recruiting an apprentice, alongside the best practices in this article.
Apprentice Supervision Guidelines UK
The legal regulations that employers must follow aren’t necessarily laid out in any one particular law or act. Instead, employers need to be aware of a handful of different regulations that govern how apprenticeships should be conducted.
Some examples or regulations and acts in place that govern certain aspects of apprenticeships are:
The obligations that employers have are often a combination of regulations pulled from different acts or policies.
While there are no laws prohibiting employers from leaving their apprentices to work without supervision, they do have to legally ensure that their apprentices are safe and sufficiently trained.
In short, they must make certain that their apprentices:
-
Are working in a safe environment
-
Are trained effectively and instructed appropriately
-
Are supervised on their role and responsibilities while building competence and confidence
Should apprentices be supervised at all times?
The answer to the question if apprentices have to be supervised 100% of the time is not very simple.
No, apprentices do not need to be supervised all the time, but they do need to have adequate supervision.
Every apprentice has different requirements for supervision based on a few factors such as:
-
Their previous experience
-
How old the apprentice is
-
The level of complexity and risk involved in the task
Routine tasks are safer to be done without supervision for apprentices with plenty of training, whereas a more junior apprentice might struggle without supervision.
High-risk tasks should always be done under supervision for all but the most experienced and senior apprentices, and even then, supervision might be required.
What does adequate supervision for apprentices look like?
What ‘adequate supervision’ means for apprentices is not quite set in stone, as every apprentice has different requirements for supervision.
However, in practice, adequate supervision for apprentices often looks like the following:
-
Clear instructions for all the tasks required
-
Access to a senior member for support and further supervision when required
-
Regular check-ins rather than looking over their shoulders
-
More independence for more competent apprentice
We often find that supervision for apprentices can be split into 3 different tiers based on how much supervision is required:
-
Low supervision: For those with evidence of their competency, or for those working on tasks with low risks.
-
Medium-level supervision: for those working on tasks they are somewhat familiar with and for those who have demonstrated growth in skill and confidence.
-
High supervision: For those new to the apprenticeship, for those starting a task they have not done before and for those working on high-risk tasks.
Best practices for apprenticeship supervision
The best way to implement supervision for apprenticeships is to set up a strong structure for offering support and oversight.
Setting up a plan that does not rely on micromanagement gives your apprentices a chance to develop their skillset in a safe environment and does not cut into their or your productivity.
There are some tried and tested models that you can implement. One example of such a model is the 4x4x4 model, developed by Tony Morrison in 2005. Mostly aimed at healthcare, this model can still be utilised by other businesses with some slight tweaks.
This model uses 4 stakeholders, 4 functions and 4 stages of reflection to determine the level of impact of the work and how to move the training and development forward. It can be used during meetings with the apprentices to quantify the work they have done and to focus on different aspects of their role depending on which stakeholder they are dealing with, which functions they are occupying and what their experiences were.
This might identify where some issues are arising for the apprentice, which can lead to a smoother experience going forward.
You can use any model you think is effective, but some of the best models tend to incorporate a few of the following methods:
-
Designated workplace mentor or supervisor to reach for larger developmental questions
-
Clear ways to ask questions and escalate if an apprentice is unsure
-
Buddy systems for day-to-day guidance and feeling more integrated within a team
-
Competency sign-off before working independently
Implementing systems focused on developing and supporting are highly effective.
Common supervision mistakes
There are some mistakes that are often made when supervising apprentices, especially with employers who have not yet worked with apprentices before.
No clear system of responsibility
Sometimes employers designate the responsibility of supervising and managing an apprentice to multiple others in the team.
While a good idea on paper, this often results in nobody taking the full responsibility, or people will be convinced the responsibility lies with someone else.
Set up a clear system of responsibility within your organisation and designate someone to ensure that supervision happens.
Too much supervision
Too much supervision is another frequent mistake.
While it does pay to be careful and considerate, there is such a thing as too much supervision.
Treating the apprentices as incapable of simple tasks and hovering over their shoulders at every moment only makes them feel more insecure in their work or frustrates them. It also takes up much of your time as a supervisor.
Lack of documentation
When working with apprentices, it does pay off to record their progress.
Writing down their training schedules, noting when someone has signed off on their supervision and recording their competence in certain areas gives you a signal to note which parts of their tasks still need supervision and when they can be left alone at their work.
How can Total People help with supervision?
Supervision might seem difficult, but with the proper planning, it is very manageable.
It pays to remember that supervision should not be constant but based on the risk and competence involved.
Apprentices can work alone when they have become more competent in their work.
Finally, a well-crafted apprenticeship plan and good supervision protect both the business and the apprentices.
If you need any help with recruiting an apprentice, or if you need assistance in setting up a plan for the apprenticeships, Total People can help.
Reach out to our experts and discuss what they can mean for you.
